This week, I testified before the Pennsylvania House Energy Committee about a rapidly escalating electric cost issue that is quietly building across our Commonwealth.
At a time when energy affordability is already a top concern for families and small businesses, Pennsylvania is facing a projected $700 million annual exposure in electric costs-- driven not by fuel prices or extreme weather, but by an unintended loophole in our net metering rules.
Net metering was created to help homeowners and small businesses install solar panels and oƯset their own energy use.
When it functions as intended, it is a fair and valuable tool that supports clean energy and grid modernization.
But today, the framework allows certain merchant solar facilities-- with little or no on-site electric demand-- to qualify for full retail-rate compensation.
These facilities sell nearly all their electricity back to the grid at the utility’s price-to-compare, which is currently about 47 percent higher than wholesale market rates.
That difference matters.
Compensation paid at retail rates is recovered from other ratepayers.
Right now, 36 facilities account for approximately $6.4 million per year in excess retail-rate compensation.
Based on projects already moving through the interconnection process, that figure is projected to exceed $90 million annually by 2027-- a more than fourteen-fold increase in just a few years.
And with more than 2,100 interconnection requests currently pending statewide, projected exposure could exceed $700 million per year if those facilities proceed under existing rules.
These costs do not disappear. They are first borne by commercial and industrial customers-- including small businesses operating on narrow margins.
Over time, they ripple outward, affecting hiring decisions, consumer prices, and ultimately residential customers as utilities recover these expenses through rates.
This is the “cost cliff” I described to lawmakers.
To be clear: this is not about opposing rooftop solar. Nor is it about discouraging renewable energy.
Distributed generation plays an important role in modernizing our grid.
This is about affordability and fairness.
Net metering was intended to offset a customer’s own electricity use-- not serve as a revenue mechanism for facilities generating power for sale at above-market retail rates.
Following a 2021 court ruling that limited the Commission’s ability to align compensation with statutory intent, the current framework permits solar facilities up to 3 MW with minimal on-site load to receive full retail-rate compensation.
In one example reviewed by the Commission, a 3 MW facility-- capable of generating
enough electricity to over 500 homes-- had an expected annual demand of just 2,000 kWh, comparable to a small residential customer.
Pennsylvania has options.
The General Assembly can clarify the statute to restore net metering to its intended purpose-- supporting true end-user customers while preventing excessive cost shifting.
Lawmakers may also consider establishing a clear framework for community solar, allowing renters, small businesses, and customers without suitable rooftops to subscribe to shared facilities and receive proportionate bill credits while ensuring costs and benefits are equitably distributed.
Energy affordability affects every employer signing payroll checks and every family opening a utility bill.
If we act now, we can prevent hundreds of millions of dollars in avoidable costs from compounding over the next several years.
Steve DeFrank serves as Chairman of the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission. Click Here for his full testimony before the House Energy Committee.
Related Articles This Week:
-- Senate PUC Budget Hearing: PUC Chair Says PJM Market Auction Not Designed For Data Center Demands; PA Needs Diversify Fuels Used To Generate Electricity; Bring Your Own Power Critical [PaEN]
-- House Committee Reports Out Bills To Require Data Centers To Disclose Energy, Water Use, Direct DCED To Develop Model Data Center Ordinance [PaEN]
-- DCNR House Budget Hearing: House Republicans Propose More Shale Drilling In State Forest Land, Under State Parks; Gas Drilling Has Caused The Loss Of 30,000 Acres Of Core State Forest Land So Far [PaEN]
-- PA Solar Center, Capital Good Fund Partner On Pennsylvania BRIGHT To Deliver Nearly 70 Solar Energy Projects Worth Up To $40 Million [PaEN]
-- Energy Efficiency Alliance: March 12 Webinar - How Virtual Power Plants Strengthen Our Grid, Protect Ratepayers [PaEN]
-- Protect PT To Hold Workshops In Plum Boro March 12, Monessen March 19 On How To Protect Your Community From Environmental Threats Caused By Shale Gas Development [PaEN]
-- The Derrick: PA US Senator McCormick Cosponsors Bill To Adopt Permitting Reforms For Electric Transmission Lines To Meet Growing Energy Demands [PDF of Article]
NewsClips:
-- PennFuture, Conservation Voters Of PA Host March 4 Webinar On How To Protect Your Community Before A.I. Data Centers Come Knocking, 6:00 to 7:00 p.m.
-- Inside Climate News - Jon Hurdle: Grassroots Resistance To A.I. Data Centers Rises In Pennsylvania
-- Tribune-Democrat: PA House Committee Sees Partisan Split On Proposals To Regulate, Monitor A.I. Data Centers
-- City & State PA: PA House Committee Advances Bills Addressing Growing Concerns With A.I. Data Centers, Republicans Opposed
-- Beaver Times Guest Essay: A.I. Data Centers Will Harm Health, Limit Jobs In Beaver County - By Elan Justice Pavlinich, Environmental Health Project
-- TribLive Guest Essay: Why Are Pennsylvanians Paying Higher Electric Bills - Data Center Demand, PJM, Natural Gas Price Spikes - By Trish Reilly, Centrist Democrats Of America
-- PA Capital-Star Guest Essay: Can Electric Grid Meet A.I. Data Center Energy Demands Without Increasing Risks For Everyone Who Depends On It? - By Shixiang Zhu, Carnegie Mellon University
-- Utility Dive: PJM Proposes Fast-Track New Generation Interconnection Plan; Extension Of Capacity Auction Price Ceiling, Collar
-- Morning Call/AP: Iran Strikes Amazon Data Centers In Middle East Highlighting Industry’s Vulnerability To Physical Disasters
[Posted: March 4, 2026] PA Environment Digest
No comments :
Post a Comment