The vote was 29 to 19 with all Republicans and Sen. Lisa Boscola (D-Lehigh) and Sen. Marty Flynn (D-Lackawanna) voting in favor.
Sen. Carolyn Comitta (D-Chester), Democratic Chair of the Senate Environmental Resources & Energy Committee, was the only member to speak on the bill.
“This resolution came up quite suddenly in a Senate Environmental Resources and Energy Committee that was [held] off the floor.
“I have a lot to say, but I will keep it brief.
“What I find most striking is that we continue to be myopically focused on conventional oil and gas.
“It's almost like there's nothing else, as if no other energy sources have been developed over the last century.
“Maybe that's why Pennsylvania still lags in deploying renewables.
“Did you know that Pennsylvania ranks 47th in the nation for the rate of growth in total solar, wind, and geothermal generation over the past decade?
“Recently, I was at Unionville High School in my district, which used the Solar for Schools grant program to install a rooftop solar system that's projected to produce one quarter of the district's power and save taxpayers $75,000 a year.
“But we just want to focus on conventional oil and gas.
“Okay, but if that's the case, why not look at the entire picture?
“Let's look closer at the health impacts. We have studies on the health impacts of fracking.
“Let's look closer at conventional oil and gas.
“Let's consider the taxpayer liability for plugging tens of thousands of orphaned and abandoned wells.
“Let's look at the failure of industry partners to comply with laws and DEP regulations.
“Let's look at the need to update industry regulations that are nearly four decades old.
“And most importantly, let's look at affordability. It's the top issue impacting my constituents, and it's only mentioned once in this resolution.
“How can we not look at consumer costs as part of this study while energy prices skyrocket?
“There's a whole lot more to consider and think about.
“But when we only look at half the picture, we're going to get results that are at best incomplete and at worst purposefully skewed, and that's wrong.
“It's misleading to the people and communities we represent. It's not fair to the voters who elected us.
“We need to focus on answering to them, not the oil and gas industry, which I might add can produce its own favorable study touting its benefits.
“Taxpayers don't need to pay for that.
“Thank you, and I will be voting no.”
Background
The resolution fails to take into account the other part of the balance sheet-- the billions of dollars in costs the industry dumps on state taxpayers in the form of thousands of abandoned, unplugged wells; widespread non-compliance with environmental laws and regulations; and road dumping and illegal disposal of contaminated water.
Conventional Wells Supply Less Than 1% Of Gas
Conventional oil wells produce roughly 800,000 to 920,000 barrels of oil annually in Pennsylvania, based on industry reports to DEP and the FracTracker Alliance.
Most of the oil is used for high-value lubricants and speciality products.
US production of crude oil is about 14 million barrels per day-- PA production is roughly 2,520 barrels per day (0.018%).
Conventional gas wells produce around 46,400,000 Mcf of gas annually according to industry reports to DEP, but that’s less than 0.6% of all natural gas production in the state and falling, according to the FracTracker Alliance.
The Independent Fiscal Office does not report on natural gas production from conventional gas wells in its quarterly natural gas reports because it is insignificant compared to shale gas production-- about 7,712,000,000 Mcf.
In fact, at the last DCED PA Crude [Oil] Development Advisory Council meeting, representatives of the conventional industry said few if any natural gas wells are being drilled because they are so uneconomical in the face of all that shale gas.
Senate Resolution 374
Senate Resolution 374 directs the Joint State Government Commission do a study that includes an examination of --
-- The current and projected economic contribution of this Commonwealth's conventional oil and natural gas industry.
-- The oil and natural gas industry's role in addressing future electricity generation demand.
-- A review of the impact of statutory and regulatory policy on small conventional operators.
-- Preserving domestic energy production capacity in this Commonwealth.
-- The energy security and supply chain benefits associated with the proximity of conventional oil and natural gas production done in this Commonwealth to regional energy markets, transportation infrastructure, manufacturing facilities and in-State refining capacity.
-- A review of differences between conventional and unconventional operations.
-- Rural workforce and economic implications associated with oil and natural gas industry decline.
-- The energy security, reliability and economic benefits associated with this Commonwealth's conventional natural gas production, gathering systems, storage facilities, distribution networks and contribution to electricity generation and industrial demand.
-- The role of conventional infrastructure in future energy reliability planning.
What’s Not Include
The study does not include information on the other side of the balance sheet-
-- Billions In Taxpayer Plugging Liability: Plugging just the 27,000 oil and gas wells abandoned by their owners and on DEP’s federal well plugging list would cost taxpayers an estimated $1.8 billion;
-- Billions In Taxpayer Plugging Liability: Plugging the roughly 200,000 abandoned and orphan wells DEP estimates are out there would cost an estimated $6.6 billion.
-- No Bonds For 60,000 Wells: Conventional oil and gas wells drilled before April 1985 do not have to have any well plugging bonds-- about 60,000 of the 105,000 active conventional wells.
-- $15 On Hand To Plug Each Well: Because of absurdly low well plugging bonding rates-- $25,000 for an unlimited number of wells-- DEP only has on hand about $15 to plug each of the wells it knows about.
-- “Widespread Non-Compliance:” In 2022 special compliance report and again in 2025, DEP said the conventional industry has a “culture of non-compliance” and it continues to see “widespread non-compliance with laws and regulations,” in particular the continuing abandonment of oil and gas wells and the failure to submit annual production, waste production and mechanical integrity reports.
-- Failure To Report Simple Things: FracTracker Alliance/DEP report recently that the owners of 81,000 of the 105,000 conventional wells required to report failed to submit any information on the amount of waste they produce.
-- Road Dumping Contaminated Water: Conventional well owners continue to illegally dispose of contaminated water by dumping it on public roads that DEP said at a House Environmental Committee hearing contains hydrocarbons, salts, heavy metals and other potential pollutants that can potentially harm water quality and drinking water supplies.
-- Regulations That Are 39 Years Old: Conventional oil and gas regulations have not been updated since 1987-- for 39 years and the last time DEP tried in 2016, the industry killed the effort.
-- Conversion To Geothermal Energy Wells: There is no mention of looking at the economic value of converting conventional wells into sources of geothermal energy as has been proposed and other alternative uses.
Click Here for the text of Senate Resolution 374.
Resource Links - Conventional Contaminated Water Dumping:
-- House Hearing I: DEP Allows The Use Of Contaminated Water From New 'Mineral Brine' Conventional Wells On Roads, While Prohibiting Contaminated Water With The Same Harmful Pollutants On Roads From Other Conventional Oil & Gas Wells [PaEN]
-- House Hearing II: Road Dumping Contaminated Water From Conventional Oil & Gas Wells Creates An Aerosol Mist Carrying Pollution Through The Air And Into My Lungs - By Siri Lawson, Warren County Resident [PaEN]
-- House Hearing III: Protect PT: For Too Long The Oil & Gas Industry Has Used Our Southwest PA Communities As Dumping Grounds For Their Waste - Road Dumping Contaminated Water From Conventional Oil & Gas Wells Must Be Banned [PaEN]
-- House Hearing IV: We Should Not Be Trying To Find New Ways To Dump More Contaminated Water From Conventional Oil & Gas Wells On Our Roads, It’s Obviously Not A Solution; We Need Safe Disposal Options - Here’s One [PaEN]
-- Conventional Oil & Gas Industry: DEP Decision To Approve Unrestricted Use Of Contaminated Water From Oil & Gas ‘Mineral Brine’ Wells Clears The Way For Uncontrolled, Free Disposal Of Contaminated Water At Public Expense And Risk [PaEN]
-- FracTracker Alliance Appeals DEP Conventional Oil & Gas Mineral Brine Well Permit Due To Concerns The Permit Creates A New Loophole For Disposing Of Contaminated Groundwater Without Testing Or Restrictions On Its Use [PaEN]
-- House Committee Moves Bills To Prohibit Road Dumping Contaminated Groundwater Released By Conventional Oil & Gas Well Drilling; Setting Minimum Standards For Power Plant Community Benefit Agreements; Encouraging Native Insect Habitats [PaEN]
-- House Committee To Consider Bills To Prohibit Road Dumping Oil & Gas Wastewater, Set Minimum Standards For Power Plant Community Benefit Agreements, Encourage Monarch, Native Insect Habitats On June 8 [PaEN]
-- New Penn State Study: Brine Water Pumped From Played-Out Conventional Oil & Gas Wells And Used As Dust Suppressants, Winter Road Treatments Exceed Environmental, Health Standards, Just Like Conventional Oil & Gas Brine Water [PaEN]
-- Late Night Road Dumping: Conventional Oil & Gas Wastewater Continues To Be Dumped On Dirt, Gravel, Paved Roads; DEP Expected To Provide Update At April 24 Meeting [4.9.25]
-- Late Night Dumping II: Conventional Oil & Gas Wastewater Dumping Continues On Roads, This Time With Bigger Trucks; New Research On Harmful Wastewater Impacts [5.22.25]
-- Senate Hearing: Penn State Expert: ‘No More Research That Needs To Be Done’ To Justify A Ban On Road Dumping Conventional Oil & Gas Wastewater [4.17.24]
-- House Hearing: Penn State Expert Says ‘Pennsylvania Should Ban Road Spreading Of Oil & Gas Wastewater;’ Contaminants Exceed Health, Environmental Standards [6.10.24]
-- House Hearing: Penn State Center For Dirt & Gravel Road Studies Says Road Spreading Oil & Gas Wastewater Is Not An Effective Dust Suppressant, Does Not Meet Environmental Testing Standards [6.10.24]
-- Moody & Associates Study Finds Discharge Of Conventional Oil & Gas Wastewater To The Ground Surface ‘Not A Viable Management Practice'; Supports Ban On Road Dumping; Onsite Disposal [5.13.24]
-- Senate Hearing: First-Hand Account Of Health, Environmental Impacts From Road Dumping Conventional Oil & Gas Wastewater - ‘Inhaling Oil & Gas Wastewater 24-Hours A Day’ [4.17.24]
-- House Hearing: A First-Hand Account Of How Repeated, Unlimited Road Dumping Of Oil & Gas Drilling Wastewater Is Tearing Apart Dirt Roads And Creating Multiple Environmental Hazards [6.10.24]
-- House Hearing: Protect PT - Road Dumping Oil & Gas Wastewater ‘Is Disproportionately Responsible For Negative Impacts On Human Health,’ Especially From Radioactive Radium [6.10.24]
-- Senate Hearing: 3.5 Million Gallons Of Conventional Oil & Gas Wastewater Dumped On PA Public Roads Since DEP’s ‘Moratorium’ On Dumping Started 6 Years Ago [4.17.24]
-- House Hearing: On Road Dumping Oil & Gas Wastewater - ‘We Studied This For Nearly 30 Years And The Conclusions Are The Same - The Wastewater Contains Harmful Contaminants’ [6.10.24]
-- Senate Hearing: The Case For An Immediate, Total Ban On Road Dumping Conventional Oil & Gas Wastewater [4.17.24]
-- House Hearing: Shapiro Administration Supports Bill Banning Road Dumping Oil & Gas Wastewater, Prohibiting Its Use As Coproduct Under Residual Waste Regulations [6.10.24]
-- Guest Essay: Take A Deep Breath! Now Think What You Just Inhaled. If You Live Along A Dirt Road You Could Be Inhaling Oil & Gas Wastewater - By Siri Lawson, Warren County [8.2.23]
-- Environmental Health Project - Part 1: Personal Narrative Of Environmental, Health Impacts From Oil & Gas Drilling On Siri Lawson, Warren County [7.16.21]
-- Environmental Health Project - Part II: Personal Narrative Of Environmental, Health Impacts From Oil & Gas Drilling On Siri Lawson, Warren County [8.5.21]
-- Op-Ed: Why Is the General Assembly About To Hurt Us By Authorizing Road Dumping Of Oil & Gas Wastewater? - By Siri Lawson [9.22.19]
-- Op-Ed: Will Our Dirt Roads Again Be Used As Dumping Sites For Oil & Gas Well Wastewater - By Siri Lawson [3.22.19]
-- Op-Ed: The Story Behind Stopping Conventional Oil & Gas Brine Spreading On Dirt Roads - By Siri Lawson [6.26.18]
PA Oil & Gas, Industry Public Notice Dashboards:
-- PA Oil & Gas Compliance Snapshot
-- DEP - Day 501: Pin Oak Energy Partners LLC Failed To Comply With Consent Order To Restore 2 Shale Gas Well Pads, Impoundment In Beaver County [PaEN]
-- Cleanup Crews Continue Recovery Of Jet Fuel, Air Monitoring Around Site Of Energy Transfer Pipeline Struck By Utility Contractor In Upper Merion Twp., Montgomery County [PaEN]
-- PA Oil & Gas Industrial Facilities: Permit Notices, Opportunities To Comment - November 14 [PaEN]
-- DEP Posted 38 Pages Of Permit-Related Notices In November 14 PA Bulletin [PaEN]
Related Articles This Week:
-- DEP Announces Plan To Place One Temporary Air Monitoring Site Near Two Large Cryogenic Natural Gas Processing Plants To Monitor For Hazardous Air Pollutants In Washington County [PaEN]
-- Senate Republicans Pass Resolution Authorizing A Taxpayer-Funded Study On The Importance Of Conventional Oil & Gas Industry; Forgetting The Billions In Costs The Industry Continues To Dump On Taxpayers [PaEN]
-- Marcellus Drilling News: Status Of 27 PA Data Centers In Permitting Process And Their Sources Of Power [PDF of Article]
-- Legislators, Environmental Leaders Unveil 100-Day Blueprint To Lower Electricity Bills, Rein In Data Centers, Expand Clean Energy [PaEN]
-- Inside Climate News/Post-Gazette: Kiley Bense, Peter Aldhous: What The World’s First Oil Boom Left Behind In Pennsylvania-- Hundreds Of Thousands Of Unplugged Conventional Oil & Gas Wells - Part I of 3
-- Post-Gazette/Inside Climate News- Anya Litvak, Kiley Bense, Peter Aldhous: In Western PA You Might Live Next To Or On Top Of An Abandoned, Unplugged Conventional Oil & Gas Well [Search For Abandoned Wells Near You] - Part 2 of 3
-- Post-Gazette/Inside Climate News- Anya Litvak, Kiley Bense, Peter Aldhous: How And Why We Mapped Pennsylvania’s Forgotten Abandoned Conventional Oil & Gas Wells - Part 3 of 3
-- National Fuel Gas: PUC Approves 3.5% Natural Gas Delivery Base Rate Increase
NewsClips:
-- TribLive: DEP Investigating ‘Seismic Event’ Near EQT Shale Gas Well Pad In Allegheny Twp., Westmoreland County
-- Inquirer - Frank Kummer: Repaired Energy Transfer Jet Fuel Pipeline Resumes Service As Spill Cleanup From Contractor Strike Continues In Upper Merion Twp., Montgomery County
-- Warren Times: DEP Issues 6 Violations From Crude Oil Spill In Warren Impacting 7 Miles Of Allegheny River
-- Observer-Reporter: South Strabane Planning Commission Tables Fossil Fuel Siting Ordinance In Washington County
-- Spotlight PA: Utility Customers Who Shop For Energy Suppliers Pay More; PUC Agrees Numbers Raise Concerns, But Root Cause Of Extra Costs Is Unclear
-- Observer-Reporter: Large Columbia Gas Natural Gas Leak At Fayette County’s Heartland Fabrication Facility Leads To Evacuations
-- Erie Times-News: Pat Black’s Erie-Based Biofuels Empire Is Being Sold, But His Debt Keeps Growing
-- The Center Square: Bucks County Company Makes Air Into Diesel And Jet Fuel
-- The Guardian: FracTracker Alliance Alleges Fossil-Fuel Industry Violated Colorado Law Over Disclosing Drilling Chemicals
[Posted: November 18, 2026] PA Environment Digest
