Chief Justice Castille will be remembered in the environmental community for authoring the 2013 Robinson Township v. Commonwealth PA Supreme Court opinion that revived the original meaning of the Environmental Rights Amendment to the Pennsylvania Constitution in declaring several provisions of the Oil and Gas Act (Act 13) unconstitutional, including a section preempting local land use regulation of shale gas operations. Read more here.
The opinion held the Environmental Rights Amendment was self-executing and outlined an affirmative duty of the state (and all local governments and agencies) to act as a trustee of our natural resources “to prevent and remedy the degradation, diminution, or depletion of our public natural resources" and to "act affirmatively to protect the environment." Read more here.
This year we also mourned the passing of Franklin Kury on August 16, 2026, who as a state Senator authored the legislation that became the Environmental Rights Amendment that was overwhelmingly passed by the voters of Pennsylvania in 1971. Read more here.
A Life Well Lived
Chief Justice Castille’s life was defined by service. Upon graduating from Auburn University in 1966 with a Bachelor of Science degree in economics, he was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the United States Marine Corps.
While serving in Vietnam, Lieutenant Castille was severely wounded by enemy gunfire. He was rescued by his platoon Sergeant, Angel Mendez, who himself was mortally wounded in the rescue.
Ron Castille lost his right leg as a result of his injuries and was medically retired from the Marine Corps in 1968.
For his valor he received the Bronze Star Medal with Combat “V,” two Purple Hearts, and other distinctions. Thereafter, he walked with crutches for the remainder of his life, yet he remained an avid golfer, downhill skier and boater.
He often remarked that he lived his life in honor of Angel Mendez and others with whom he served who made the ultimate sacrifice.
In 1993, Castille was elected a Justice of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. He took office in January 1994 and was retained by the voters in 2003 and 2013.
On January 14, 2008, he was sworn in as Chief Justice of Pennsylvania, the 55th Chief Justice in Pennsylvania history, serving in that capacity until his mandatory retirement at age 70 on December 31, 2014.
Click Here for more on his life and accomplishments.
Appreciations
John C. Dernbach, Distinguished Professor Of Law, Widener University, gave this tribute to Chief Justice Castille--
Chief Justice Ronald Castille’s landmark 2013 opinion in Robinson Township v. Commonwealth brought Pennsylvania’s constitutional environmental rights amendment (Article I, Section 27) back to life after four decades of judicially-imposed dormancy. It is a capstone of his long and distinguished career in public service.
To understand the significance of that case, it is necessary to go back to 1969, when a young lawyer and legislator from Sunbury named Franklin Kury introduced Article I, Section 27 on the House floor.
As part of the process for amending the constitution, both Houses of the General Assembly approved this proposal in two consecutive legislative sessions.
Before doing so, however, they amended it four times because they understood that its text mattered and they wanted to get it right.
Then the public approved it in May 1971 by a four-to-one vote. Kury, who passed away on August 16, 2026 championed this effort.
The amendment creates two kinds of public rights. The first is a right to clean air, pure water, and to the preservation of the natural, scenic, historic, and esthetic values of the environment.
The second is the public’s right, as the beneficiary of a public trust in public natural resources, to have those resources conserved and maintained by the Commonwealth for the benefit of present and future generations.
Yet nearly all of this was lost for four decades. Essentially, the courts employed a toothless balancing test as a substitute for the amendment’s text.
All of that changed on December 19, 2013, in the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Robinson Township v. Commonwealth.
In this case, the Court held unconstitutional several different provisions of Act 13 of 2012, the Marcellus shale legislation.
Chief Justice Castille authored a 162 page opinion on behalf of himself and two other justices (Todd, S. McCaffery), based on Article I, Section 27.
Justice Baer provided a fourth vote (out of seven justices) for the unconstitutionality of these provisions, based on substantive due process.
Chief Justice Castille’s opinion in Robinson Township profoundly changed the legal landscape concerning Article I, Section 27.
Most fundamentally, the case was decided based on the text of Article I, Section 27 and traditional rules of constitutional interpretation, and not the balancing test that had been employed for decades.
In so doing, Chief Justice Castille restored the original meaning and understanding of the amendment.
The effect was dramatic. It was as if Article I, Section 27 suddenly appeared in the law books on that date.
Lawyers and policy makers found themselves quite literally reading the text of the amendment for the first time, even though it had been enacted in 1971.
In addition, the opinion recognized a fundamental point that had been lost in the previous four decades—that Article I, Section 27 is in Pennsylvania’s Declaration of Rights—our bill of rights.
The environmental rights in Section 27, Chief Justice Castille wrote, “are on par with, and enforceable to the same extent as, any other right reserved to the people in Article I.”
On the night that the opinion was issued, I spoke with Franklin Kury. “In terms of what we intended,” he said, Chief Justice Castille “really got it right.”
Professor Mary Wood of the University of Oregon Law School, who has published a book about the public trust doctrine (Nature’s Trust, 2013), described Castille’s opinion to me as “transformative,” and called it “the most detailed judicial iteration of the public trust obligation ever rendered.”
It would be four years before Chief Justice Castille’s plurality opinion commanded a solid majority of the state Supreme Court.
Justice Donohue’s 2017 opinion in Pennsylvania Environmental Defense Foundation v. Commonwealth employed Castille’s Robinson Township framework to hold several statutory provisions unconstitutional.
To be sure, a great many issues about the meaning and applicability of Article I, Section 27 have yet to be resolved.
But the scholarly, detailed, and thoughtful nature of this opinion, coupled with its adherence to traditional rules of constitutional interpretation and its understanding that each of us possesses constitutional rights in the environment, almost certainly means that we will be able to count on reinvigorated judicial protection of these rights for generations to come.
The opinion continues to influence lawyers and policy makers in Pennsylvania, in other states, and around the world.
And for that, we can all thank Chief Justice Ronald Castille.
John Childe, an environmental attorney deeply involved in Environmental Rights Amendment court cases said this about Justice Castille--
I didn't know Justice Castille. I had not had any arguments before him. But I know what it took for him to write one of the most significant opinions in Pennsylvania Constitutional Law.
The 2013 Robinson Township case was not the first time Article I Section 27 was before him. The 2009 Supreme Court decision in Belden and Blake which he participated in did not foretell the future.
He and I shared a similar past. We both served in Vietnam. He was there in 1967. I followed him there in January of 1968.
Coming out of that experience was not easy. But we both chose similar paths, going to law school.
I know my experience led me to make the choices I did in my legal career. Did his experience lead him to write Robinson Township?
I know in 2013 he dug deep into what Article I Section 27 means.
His opinion established the Amendment as one of the most powerful civil rights created by our Constitution.
Not only the rights of the people to their natural resources, It has created the rights of the natural resources themselves, to be conserved and maintained.
He has made his peace.
Michael Sklaroff, Executive Director, Pennsylvania Bipartisan Climate Initiative, said this about Chief Justice Castille--
The most important decision in the development of climate jurisprudence in Pennsylvania is likely that of former Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille in the case of Robinson Township, in 2013.
There, the Chief Justice wrote an opinion striking down Act 13, a bill that would have permitted fracking throughout the Commonwealth, irrespective of local zoning.
In so doing, the Chief Justice revived Article I, Section 27, of the Pennsylvania Constitution, Pennsylvania’s Environmental Bill of Rights, the “ERA.”
The ERA provides that all public officials, elected and appointed, are trustees for the environment and that all people in Pennsylvania, including future generations, are beneficiaries of that trust and entitled to a livable environment.
Moreover, the ERA is in our Bill of Rights, on the same level as other fundamental rights, such as the right to vote, to own property, to worship and freedom of the press.
Importantly, the ERA is self-executing, meaning that it governs without further action of any public agency.
The ERA had passed both houses of the Legislature unanimously in 1971 and by referendum throughout the Commonwealth in a vote of four to one.
Unfortunately, lower court decisions and administrative actions by state agencies had neutered the ERA and created flawed precedent.
The Chief Justice’s opinion in Robinson Township, joined in by two Democratic justices, was supported in later Pennsylvania Supreme Court decisions.
In the years following Robinson Township, state agencies and local government agencies have begun to cite the ERA in their decisions, as Governor Shapiro has in a recent statement on data centers.
Chief Justice Castille’s work in Robinson Township shall continue to be the guiding light of planning and zoning in Pennsylvania and shall protect the health of our children and grandchildren well into the future.
Resource Links:
-- Recognition of Environmental Rights For Pennsylvania Citizens: A Tribute To Chief Justice Castille - By John C. Dernback and Marc Prokopchak, Widener University School of Law
-- Op-Ed: Taking The Public Trust Seriously: The PA Supreme Court's Landmark Decision in PEDF v. Commonwealth - By John Dernbach, Distinguished Professor Of Law, Widener University [PaEN]
-- In Memoriam: Franklin L. Kury, Author Of The Environmental Rights Amendment To The Pennsylvania Constitution [PaEN]
[Posted: November 5, 2026] PA Environment Digest

No comments:
Post a Comment